Montaigne Auerbach assignment

This is all you have to turn in to me as a word document at [email protected] (you can use the program SnapNDrag for Mac to take screen captures).

Richard Burt (only you will give your name, not mine)

The Essays, Book 2, 37 "On the Resemblance of Children to their Fathers" (only you give the same information for your examples)

Erich Auerbach, "L'Humaine condition," in Mimesis: The Representation of Reality in Western Literature - New and Expanded Edition, Trans, Willard R. Trask, ed. Edward W. Said, pp. 285-311.

A. Auerbach's version (screengrab of the page):

B. The wikisource translation: 'I have a mind to represent the progress of my humours, and that every one may see each piece as it came from the forge. I could wish I had begun sooner, and had taken more notice of the course of my mutations. . . . I am grown older by seven or eight years since I began; nor has it been without same new acquisition: I have, in that time, by the liberality of years, been acquainted with the stone: their commerce and long converse do not well pass away without some such inconvenience." Book II, Chapter_XXXVII (EA, 292)

C. The full quotation of the passage in English (without any ellipses), if necessary, as it is in this case:

I have a mind to represent the progress of my
humours, and that every one may see each piece as it came from the forge.
I could wish I had begun sooner, and had taken more notice of the course
of my mutations. I have a mind to represent the progress of my
humours, and that every one may see each piece as it came from the forge.
I could wish I had begun sooner, and had taken more notice of the course
of my mutations. A servant of mine whom I employed to transcribe for me,
thought he had got a prize by stealing several pieces from me, wherewith
he was best pleased; but it is my comfort that he will be no greater a
gainer than I shall be a loser by the theft. I am grown older by seven
or eight years since I began; nor has it been without same new
acquisition: I have, in that time, by the liberality of years, been
acquainted with the stone: their commerce and long converse do not well
pass away without some such inconvenience. Book II, Chapter_XXXVII (EA, 292)

D. The google translation. “I want to represent the progress of my moods, and see each piece in its birth. I would like to have started more and to recognize the trein of my mutations. . . . I have been envy of seven or six years since I began: it has not been without some new acquest. I practiced colic by the liberality of years. Their trade and long conversation is not easy without some fruit.”

E. A modern translation, this one by M.A. Screech (screengrab):

../Pictures/SnapNDrag%20Library.snapndraglibrary/d453c79a8/screenshot_1260.png

Et voila! That is it! Step 5 is finished. You may proceed to Step 5.5 (email it to me at [email protected]).

This is how you get there.

Preparing for Step 5

YOUR FIRST ASSIGNEMENT Due Tuesday, January 8 by 5:00 p.m.: One discussion question on How to Live: Or A Life of Montaigne in One Question and Twenty Attempts at an Answer, and three BIG WORDS, numbered one, two, and three, on each reading. Put your name at the top left of the document. Email all work to me at [email protected] . With One Exception, Discussion Questions are due the day before class on Sundays and Tuesdays by 5:00 p.m.

January 7: Cheerful, Chilly, and Cranky / Free Spirits and Free Thinkers

We will read three some of the major works of cheerful thinkers in relation to some of these broad questions: Do You Have an Opinion? What Does It Mean to Think for Yourself? The Primacy of Doxa Over Episteme / Moral Philosophy (Socrates, "What Is The Good?"; "What Is Truth?") vs Political Philosophy (Hobbes and Locke, "What is good for me?") / Censorship (Hume) / Dialectic and Rhetoric: Aristotle, Schopenhauer, pp. 102-03; 94-97; 40-41;112-15;173; 399-40; 338-41; 282-88; 423-432; 350-51; 335-44) / Liars for Hire (Sophists) versus Physicians of the Soul (Socrates) / (Anti-) / (Neoliberal / STEM) Education versus Ignorance (What is a good education?) / Memory versus Forgetting / Opinion versus Taste / Aesthetic Judgment and Critical Judgment (Kant) / How to Live? How to Die? / Persuasion and Coercion / Thinking for Yourself vs. Groupthink /Questioning and Answering (Responding) / Freedom of Thought / Freedom of Expression / Public and Publicity / Posterity System / Opinion System / Secular and Theological Close Reading

Skepticism Thoughts: Did You Read It? How Well Do You Know What You've Read? How Much Do You Remember? Is rote memorization the same thing as knowing what You've memorized? How many times did you read it? Over how long a period of time? the Importance of Other Readers to Your Reading (Reading is solitary and social.)

Bach, Cello Suite 5 Yo-Yo Ma "Courante"

Whereby may be seen that nothing is so hard or so uncertaine to be found out as the certaintie of the truth, sithence no man can put any assured confidence concerning the truth of a battel, neither in the knowledge of him that was Generall or commanded over it, nor in the soldiers that fought, of anything that hath hapned amongst them; except after the manner of a strict point of law, the severall witnesses are brought and examined face to face, and that all matters be nicely and thorowly sifted by the objects and trials of the successe of every accident. Verily the knowledge we have of our owne affaires is much more barren and feeble. But this hath sufficiently been handled by Bodin, and agreeing with my conception. Somewhat to aid the weaknesse of my memorie and to assist her great defects; for it hath often been my chance to light upon bookes which I supposed to be new and never to have read, which I had not understanding diligently read and run over many years before, and all bescribled with my notes; I have a while since accustomed my selfe to note at the end of my booke (I meane such as I purpose to read but once) the time I made an end to read it, and to set downe what censure or judgement I gave of it; that so it may at least at another time represent unto my mind the aire and generall idea I had conceived of the Author in reading him. I will here set downe the Copie of some of my annotations, and especially what I noted upon my Guicciardine about ten years since: (For what language soever my books speake unto me I speake unto them in mine owne.) He is a diligent Historiographer and from whom in my conceit a man may as exactly learne the truth of such affaires as passed in his time, as of any other writer whatsoever: and the rather because himselfe hath been an Actor of most part of them and in verie honourable place.

--Michel de Montaigne, "Of Bookes"

January 9

Required Reading:

1. Sarah Bakewell, How to Live: Or A Life of Montaigne in One Question and Twenty Attempts at an Answer, "Chapter 4: Q: How to live? Read a lot, forget most of what you read, and be slow-witted," pp. 64-89.

Recommended (Not Required) Readings and Viewings:

Thedorno Adorno, "The Essay as Form," New German Critique, No. 32 (Spring - Summer, 1984), pp. 151-171

"Michel de Montaigne, the inventor of the modern personal essay and the writer to whom modern essayists endlessly return, is renowned for his tendency to go off topic. His chapter “Des coches” (“Of Vehicles” or “Of Coaches”), for example, begins with remarks about authors, goes on to sneezing and fear, then touches quite briefly on the subject of coaches before proceeding to kings, gifts, amphitheaters, the impossibility of knowledge, and the civilizations of the New World. It ends with a story about the king of Peru, whose soldiers carry him into battle against the Spanish invaders on a chair of gold mounted on golden shafts. His men are killed, one by one, but each time a bearer falls, another leaps to replace him, keeping the king aloft on his perilously wobbling seat, until at last he is dragged down and taken prisoner. A gold litter—we belatedly realize—could be classified as a vehicle, so Montaigne has come back to his subject after all. But by this time we are so disoriented, and have traveled such a long distance, that we are as off-balance as the king and scarcely know where we are."

--Sarah Bakewell, "Reverie and Ambush: On the Influence of Montaigne"

First English Edition of Michel de Montaigne’s Essays (1603)

Shakespeare's Montaigne, the Florio Translation of the Essays, Selections "That to Philosophize Is Learning How to Die"

January 10 (Nothing Due, it's Thursday)

January 11 (Nothing Required, it's Friday)

At Berkeley (dir. Frederick Wiseman, 2013)

Montaigne, extra (on reading)

NOTE BENE: Your First Paper (500 words, not including quotations) will be DUE Saturday February 2 by 11:59 p.m. You may write your paper on any text we have read. I encourage you to make up your own paper topic. If you need any help, just email or talk to me in class and we can schedule a time to talk.

Due Sunday, January 13 by 5:00 p.m.: Two discussion questions on Michel de Montaigne, "Of Bookes" and three BIG WORDS, numbered one, two, and three. Put your name at the top left of the document. Email all work to me at [email protected] With One Exception, Discussion Questions are due the day before class on Sundays and Tuesdays by 5:00 p.m.

January 14 Remembering What You've Read, or Not

Required Reading:

--Michel de Montaigne, "Of Bookes," Book 2, Chapter 10, 359-71 in Donald Frame (pp. 457-71, in M. A. Screech)

Recommended Reading:

Richard L. Regosin, "Montaigne's Dutiful Daughter," in Montaigne's Unruly Brood: Textual Engendering and the Challenge to Paternal Authority

Keffer, K., A Publication History of the Rival Transcripts of Montaigne's Essays (2001)

a-poem-about-your-universitys-new-and-totally-not-time-wasting-review-process-for-tenure-and-promotion

Due Tuesday, January 15 by 5:00 p.m.: Two discussion questions on Pierre Bayard, "Chapter IV: Books You Have Forgotten" and three BIG WORDS, numbered one, two, and three. Put your name at the top left of the document. Email all work to me at [email protected] Discussion Questions are due the day before class on Sundays and Tuesdays by 5:00 p.m. With One exception, nothing is due Thursdays for class on Fridays.

January 16 Pile Up: The Problem of Medium and Memory, or Storage and Retrieval (Analog versus Digital?)

Required Reading:

Pierre Bayard, "Chapter IV: Books You Have Forgotten," in How to Talk About Books You Haven't Read" 2007, 32-46

Recommended Thinking: If we can't remember what we've read, have we even read what we read, I mean, have we necessarily or ever read what the author wrote? I don't mean that the author had laspes of memory when writing the book. I mean has the publisher / editor produced a reliable edition? What would "reliable" mean? What happens when there is more than one edition of the same book? Should one read the versions comparatively? Take Montaigne's three editions and posthumously published "Bordeaux Manuscript" as independent versions even if each edition was published under the same title? Should one read Montaigne with or without an editorial apparatus that uses letters to distinguish material added to each edition? Sarah Baker says that had Montaigne's writing became increasingly incomphrensible to his friends and that lived longer, he would have eventually made his work unreadable. She compares the Essays to Laurence Sterne's Tristram Shandy. Does Skepticism ever stop? Or does it just keep going until we cannot be sure we have read a text or that the text itself is what the author wrote? Is there any limit to what Montaigne calls the uncertainty of truth?

O'Brien, J. "Are We Reading What Montaigne Wrote?" French Studies, 58 (2004), 527-532.

Maurice Merleau-Ponty, “Reading Montaigne,” in Signs, trans. and ed. Richard C. McCleary (Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press, 1964), 198–210.

Can we still read Montaigne?

Gérard Defaux and John A. Gallucci, "Readings of Montaigne," Yale French Studies No. 64, Montaigne: Essays in Reading (1983), pp. 73-92

January 17: Nothing is Due (It's Thursday)

January 18: Nothing is Due (It's Friday)

Giving Up the Ghost: Michel de Montaigne, "Letter to His Father: On the Death of Étienne de la Boétie," and "That to Philosophize Is Learning How to Die"

The Bordeaux Copy

The Book People of Fahrenheit 451

Book of Eli ending

A Journey Round my Room (1794 / 1871)

Les "Essais" de Montaigne. Un exemplaire exceptionnel sur Gallica

You can buy your own copy of the color reproduction of the Bordeaux Copy of Montaigne's Essais, published in July 2002!

And you can also buy a copy ofLes Essais. Edition nouvelle prise sur l exemplaire trouvé après le deceds de l autheur, reveu augmenté d un tiers oultre les précédentes impressions. Enrichi de deux tables curieusement exactes et élabourées!

De la sagesse : trois livres. T. 1 / par Pierre Charron

Charron, Pierre, 1541-1603 De la sagesse; trois livre

Essais de Michel seigneur de Montaigne. Cinquiesme edition

Gore Vidal’s review of The Complete Essays, edited by M. A. Screech, appeared in the TLS of June 26 1992.

January 21 Martin Luther King Jr. Day! Please do not fall for the bogus right-wing "we are nto a racist country" white-washing of MLK Jr. He was always a radical, and he courageously gave this speech against the Viet Nam War shortly before he was assassinated. I was 13 years old at the time. I did not hear this speech until decades later. We have not come very far since then, imo. Even many ways we gone backwards. "Martin Luther King Jr. courageously spoke out about the Vietnam War. We must do the same when it comes to this grave injustice of our time."

Because Monday, January 21 is a Holiday, DQs will not be due Sunda,y January 20. They will be due, however on Tuesday January 23 and Thursday, January 24. (This is the one exception.)

Due on Tuesday January 22 by 5:00 p.m. DQs and BIG WORDS on Montaigne's "Of Practice," Book 2, Chapter 6, 324-33; DF trans; 416-27 (MAS)

Wednesday, January 23 Montaigne's Pyrronism

"'When I play with my cat, how do I know that she is not playing with me rather than I with her?"

1. Required Reading:

Montaigne, "Of Practice," Book 2, Chapter 6, 324-33 (DF); 416-27 (MAS)

2. Required Viewing, but no DQs (it's very short):

Sarah Bakewell introduces How to Live: A Life of Montaigne

Due Thursday, January 24 by 5:00 p.m.: Two discussion question on Montaigne's "Of Repentance," and one DQ on Erich Auerbach's "L'Humaine condition, as well as three BIG WORDS, numbered one, two, and three from both readings. Put your name at the top left of the document. Email all work to me at [email protected]

Friday January 25 Skepticism, Stoicism

Montaigne, "Of Repentance," Book 3, Chapter 2, pp. 740-752 (DF); 907-21 (MAS)

Recommended Reading:

"Moy le primiere" and other "firsts"

Lucius Annaeus Seneca. Moral Epistles. Translated by Richard M. Gummere. The Loeb Classical Library. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard UP, 1917-25. 3 vols.: Volume I. (Montaigne quoted Seneca more often than he did anywone else. He quoted from the letters most often.)

Due Sunday, January 27 by 5:00 p.m.: Translations of French in Erich Auerbach's "L'Humaine condition," Instead of two discussion questions on Erich Auerbach's "L'Humaine condition," and three BIG WORDS, numbered one, two, and three. Put your name at the top left of the document. Email all work to me at [email protected]

Monday January 28

Erich Auerbach, "L'Humaine condition," in Mimesis: The Representation of Reality in Western Literature - New and Expanded Edition, Trans, Willard R. Trask, ed. Edward W. Said, pp. 285-311.

Recommended Reading:

Lives, the Dryden Plutarch. Rev. by Arthur Hugh Clough

(Plutarch was one of Montaigne's major inspirations.)

HEADS UP: First Paper (500 words, not including quotations) DUE Saturday February 16 by 11:59 p.m. Read an essay by Montaigne of your choosing and read it the way Auerbach reads "Of Repentance" in his chapter "L'Humaine condition," Pick an essay of your choosing and take a passage from it you take to be central to it.

Due Tuesday, January 29 by 5:00 p.m.: Two discussion questions on Ralph Waldo Emerson "Montaigne, or the Skeptic" as well as three BIG WORDS, numbered one, two, and three. Put your name at the top left of the document. Email all work to me at [email protected]

Wednesday January 30 Skepticism, Stoicism

Ralph Waldo Emerson "Montaigne, or the Skeptic," 326-47.

This is the 1685-86 Cotton translation of the Essays Emerson read and that he mentions in his essay.

You might want to come back to the Cotton translation later in the semester if you find you have time to compare it to Frame's and Screech's translation. The preface is worth reading. We will be reading this edition:

Friday February 1 (Nothing Due) I will be way in Los Angeles for my mother's funeral this day.

The Loser Moment: From time to time, I will take a moment to read you a passage from a work I like or play music for you and talk about it or show you a painting and talk about it. You can play with the lighting. I will have a flashlight so I can read in the dark. Students are welcome to take your own loser moments. If you like the moment, please do a slow clap. But be sure not to join in the clapping. Since it will have been a loser moment, a failed slow clap is the best response.

DQs due Sundays and Tuesdays by 5:00 p.m. for the rest of the semester.

February 4

Required Reading:

Michel de Montaigne, "Of Vanity," Book 3, Chapter 9, pp. 876-932 (DF)

Recommended Reading:

"An Apology for Raymond Sebond," pp. 386-554. This is one of Montaigne's most famous essays, and it is also one of his longest.

"An Apology of Raymond Sebond (selections) 2.12" in Shakespeare's Montaigne, the Florio Translation of the Essays, Selections, Ed.Stephen Greenblatt, pp. 142-89. If we had time, we could compare the full version to the abridged version and see what Greenblatt leaves in and what he leaves out.

February 6

Required Reading:

Michel de Montaigne, "Of Vanity," Book 3, Chapter 9, pp. 876-932 (DF)

February 8

Required Reading (but no DQs):

Michel de Montaigne, "Of Vanity," Book 3, Chapter 9, pp. 876-932 (DF)

Recommended Reading:

Michel de Montaigne, "An Apology for Raymond Sebond," pp. 386-554.

"Of the Consistency of Our Actions," pp. 290-96.

February 11 Emerson Before and After the Death of His Son Waldo

Required Reading:

Ralph Waldo Emerson, "Circles," pp. 186-99.

February 13

Required Reading:

Ralph Waldo Emerson, "The Harvard Divinity School Address," pp. 100-19.

February 15: The Opinion System

DUE Saturday February 16: First Paper (500 words, not including quotations) by 11:59 p.m. Read an essay by Montaigne of your choosing and read it the way Auerbach reads "Of Repentance" in his chapter "L'Humaine condition," Pick an essay of your choosing and take a passage from it you take to be central to it. Then read that passage closely. For more, see below at the end of the schedule.

Recommended Reading:

Kurt Wetters, "Lichtenberg's Opinions-System"

Theodor W. Adorno,"Opinion Research and Publicness (Meinungsforschung und Offentlichkeit)

Theodor W. Adorno, "Opinion Delusion Society"

Thomas Hobbes: A grim portrait of human nature

NYT Opinion Writer Can't Remember Why She Hates Tulsi Gabbard--Perfect example of Wetters' analysis of John Locke (you often can't remember why you hold your opinions)

NY Times Writer Criticizes Tulsi Gabbard| Joe Rogan

February 18: Montaigne and His Covenant Daughter, Marie de Gournay

Required Reading:

Montaigne, "Of Experience," pp. 992-1048

Live Grading

February 20

Required Reading:

Ralph Waldo Emerson, "Experience," pp. 223-47

Live Grading

Recommended Reading:

Sharon Cameron, "Representing Grief: Emerson's 'Experience'," Representations No. 15 (Summer, 1986), pp. 15-41

February 22

Recommended Reading:

Walter Benjamin on habit and attention, Montaigne on "Diversion," Blaise Pascal on "Divertissement," and Paul North on The Problem of Distraction

February 25

Required Reading:

Ralph Waldo Emerson, "Nature," 27-70; "Fate," "Power," "Illusions," 400-56.

February 27 Nietzsche and His Sister

Required Reading: Friedrich Nietzsche, Anti-Education: On the Future of Our Educational Institutions

March 1

Recommended Reading:

On neoliberal education:

"The company eagerly cultivates an academic aura, and the facility is
referred to as its “campus.” The campus bookstore sells dozens of
business books, of the kind ubiquitous in airport newsstands. Typical
selections included The World’s Most Powerful Leadership Principle:
How to Become a Servant Leader (featuring a jacket blurb from the
Senior Vice President of Operations for Chik-fil-a) and Leading with
Soul: An Uncommon Journey of Spirit. Alas, they did not have my
favorite managerial tome of all time, If Harry Potter Ran General
Electric: Leadership Wisdom from the World Of Wizards, which is a
genuine, honest-to-God book that you can look up and purchase."

https://www.currentaffairs.org/2016/06/the-unendurable-horrors-of-leadership-camp

If you need to relax . . . . (go directly to time stamp 1:54)

Neoliberalese at the corporate university: "Raising Awareness"

March 3: The Immorality of Moral Studies

Required Viewing and Reading:

At Berkeley (dir. Frederick Wiseman, 2013)

Friedrich Nietzsche, Anti-Education: On the Future of Our Educational Institutions

March 5-9 Spring Break

March 11

Required Reading:

Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche, "Schopenhauer as Educator" in Unfashionable Observations Volume 2 (The Complete Works of Friedrich Nietzsche) Richard T. Gray, Stanford University Press, pp. 169-256 and relevant endnote pages.

March 13

Required Reading:

Nietzsche: The Anti-Christ, Ecce Homo, Twilight of the Idols: And Other Writings

March 15 "Reading Nietzsche as a Loser"

Recommended Reading:

Malcolm Bull, "Anti-Nietzsche," in Anti-Nietzsche (2014) pp. 27-54

Malcolm Bull, "Where is the Anti-Nietzsche?" in NLR 3, May-June 2000, pp. 121-145

March 18

Required Readings:

1. Stanley Cavell, "Old and New in Emerson and Nietzsche," in Emerson's Transcendental Etudes (Stanford UP, 2003), , pp. 223-233.

2. Nietzsche, The Anti-Christ, Ecce Homo, Twilight of the Idols: And Other Writings

March 20

Required Reading:

Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche, The Genealogy or Morals, the Fourth Treatise (on cruelty and memory)

March 22

Recommended Reading:

Michel de Montaigne, "Of Cruelty"

Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche, The Genealogy or Morals, the Third Treatise

Second Paper (500 words, not including quotations) DUE Saturday, March 23 by 11:59 p.m. You may write your paper on any text we have so far. I encourage you to make up your own paper topic. If you need any help, just email or talk to me in class and we can schedule a time to talk.

March 25

Required Readings:

Michel de Montaigne, "A Custom of the Isle of Cea"

March 27 ACCIDENT OCCASIONNE PAR UN CHIEN

Required Reading:

"Un accident incontestable est longuement raconté dans la promenade de la « Seconde Rêverie »"

Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Reveries of the Solitary Walker, Second Reverie, 11-19. (This essay recalls Montaign'es "Of Practice.")

Recommended Reading:

Michel de Montaigne, "Of Coaches," Essays, Book Three, Chapter Six.

Jacques Derrida, Session Eleven, Death Penalty Seminar, Vol. 1, pp. 270-83.

March 29

Recommended Reading:

Jean-Jacques Rousseau, "Second Reverie" of Reveries of the Solitary Walker

April 1

Recommended Reading:

TBA

April 3: Billiards

David Hume, "Section IV: Skeptical Doubts Concerning the Operations of the Understanding," An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, 18-29.

April 5: Billiards

Required Reading:

David Hume, "Section IV: Skeptical Doubts Concerning the Operations of the Understanding," An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, 18-29.

EnquiryconcerningHumanUnderstandingSectionXIIOftheAcademicalorSkepticalPhilosophy.pdf

Recommended Readings:

David Hume, "Section XII: Of the Academical or Skeptical Philosophy," An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding

liii-lvi; 109-120. EnquiryconcerningHumanUnderstandingSectionXIIOftheAcademicalorSkepticalPhilosophy.pdf

Plato, The Sophist and Gorgias

David Edmonds and John Eidinow, Rousseau's Dog: Two Great Thinkers at War in the Age of Enlightenment

Henri Guillemin, Jean-Jacques Rousseau. l'affaire Jean-Jacques Rousseau - David Hume, 1766 / Volume 2, Cette affaire infernale

April 8 Stoicism--Philosophy is Learning How to Die

Required Readings:

1.Michel de Montaigne, "That to Philosophize Is Learning How to Die," in Shakespeare's Montaigne, the Florio Translation of the Essays, Selections, Ed.Stephen Greenblatt, pp. 13-33.

2. Michel de Montaigne, "To His Father: On the Death of La Boétie," in Complete Works of Montaigne, Trans. Donald Frame, 1276-88.

April 10

Required Reading:

David Hume, "My Own Life"

Seneca, "On the Shortness of Life"

Recommended Reading:

Thomas De Quincey, The Last Days of Immanuel Kant

Les Derniers Jours D'Emmanuel Kant (The Last Days of Immanuel Kant w/ English subs)

Sigmund Feud, "My Contact with Josef Popper-Lynkeus" (1932)

Two Animations of Plato’s Allegory of the Cave: One Narrated by Orson Welles, Another Made with Clay

When Nietzsche Wept (dir. Pinchas Perry, 2007)

April 12

Recommended Viewing:

A Tale of Winter (dir. Eric Rohmer, 1992)

Recommended Reading:

Stanley Cavell, "Shakespeare and Rohmer," in Cities of Words

April 15 to 17 I will be in Chongping and Hang Zhou giving invited lectures on Shakespeare

April 15 On always being right vs. being a dialectician (a good physician)

Arthur Schopenhauer, The Art Of Controversy

Revised in Arthur Schopenhauer, "Chapter 2: On Logic and Dialectic," in Parerga and Paralipomena: Volume 2: Short Philosophical Essays (The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Schopenhauer) The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Schopenhauer

The Art of Being Right

The Art of Being Right: 38 Ways to Win an Argument

Stanley Fish, "The aesthetic of the good physician," in Self-Consuming Artifacts.

Required Reading:

April 17 Hobbes versus Locke?: The shared problems of enthusiasm, memory, opinion, forgetting

John Locke, Some Thoughts Concerning Education, 1692

Recommended Reading:

April 19

Required Reading:

Kirk Wetters, "Chapter Three: The Opinion System and the Re-formation (Hobbes, Locke, Mendelssohn, Fichte, and Goethe)," in The Opinion System: Impasses of the Public Sphere from Hobbes to Habermas (2008), 123-78

April 22 Public Opinion and Literature

Required Reading:

Jacques Derrida, "CALL IT A DAY FOR DEMOCRACY''

April 24

Final Paper DUE APRIL 23 (topics to be determined) Derrida on Blaise Pascal's posthumously note sewn into his vest.

Ninth Session of the The Beast and the Sovereign, Vol. 2, pp. 211-14

RICHARD PARISH, "ETAT PRESENT BLAISE PASCAL," French Studies, Vol. LXXI, No. 4, 2017, 539–550.

FOR YOUR FIRST AND SECOND PAPERS:

If you need any help, just email or talk to me in class and we can schedule a time to talk. Close reading and writing as you read are exploratory and experimental. That's what's cool about close reading. You can have a very good idea of what you want to pay attention to, but you can't really program what will be read or how it will be read exactly in advance. And when you do get "a read" on the book, you'll know it is provisional, that you'll only know the book as well as do a good friend (or, dare I say, a lover). There are tacit rules, but there is no referee, just a reader. The idea is to be less inhibited about your own writing when you read, as in, “you can say that? And say it that way? Really?!” Yes, you can. And more. Your assignment is to do a close reading of an assigned text. Focus on a passage or just a sentence and discuss it in detail in order to illuminate something more general about the text you're writing about. That passage is your paper topic. Cite the text to make your points. The text is your evidence. If you don't know what a close reading is and have never done one before, be sure to go to http://writingcenter.fas.harvard.edu/pages/how-do-close-reading. You may also ask me for clarification. You must also know how to write a research paper, or analytical essay. You will need a title for your paper and a thesis, an argument that you can state in one sentence. Your thesis should go at the end of your first paragraph. You may figure out your title before you write your paper, but usually, you only figure out your title after you figure out your thesis. And you figure out your thesis by writing your paper. What you think is your conclusion often needs to be moved up from the end of the essay to the front. Then you are ready to make your final revisions and add a new concluding paragraph. You may also have come up with a new title in the course of writing the paper. And then you are ready to proofread your paper. And then you will have finished writing your paper. Congratulations! :) Email your paper (as an attachment) to me at [email protected]. Put your name in the subject title or header of your title. Remember to put your name in your paper.

Nothing below is required for this course:

Auerbach’s expanded version emended version of first paragraph of Du Repentir

Les autres forment l'homme: je le recite; et en represente un particulier bien mal forme, et lequel si j'avoy a faconner de nouveau, je ferois vrayment bien autre qu'il n'est. Meshuy, c'est fait.
--Montaigne,
Auerbach quotes from Montaigne's Essais. Ed. Villey (Paris, Akan, 1930)
To make this point clearer, let me supply some syntactic vinicula: (Tandis que) les autres forrnent l'homme, je le recite; (encore faut-il ajouter que) fe represente un particulier (; ce particulier, c'est moi-meine, qui suis, je le sais,) bien mal forme; (soyez surs que) si l’avais ale faqonner de nouveau, je le ferais vrayment bien autre qu'il n'est. (Mais, malheureusement) meshuy c'est fait.
--Auerbach’s emended version with vinicula added
Others form man; I describe him, and portray a particular, very ill-made one, who, if I had to fashion him anew, should indeed be very different from what he is. But now it is done.
--The Essays of Montaigne. Translated by E. J. Trechmann, Oxford University Press, 1927. The translation Auerbach uses.
(While) others form man; I describe him, (yet I must add that) I portray a particular (this particular, it’s myself, who am, I know it), very ill-made one (you can be sure of that), who, if I had to fashion him anew, should indeed be very different from what he is. (But, unfortunately) now it is done.
--My translation of Auerbach’s emended translation with vinicula supplied

Due Tuesday, January 29 by 5:00 p.m.: Two discussion questions on Heinrich von Kleist, "On the Gradual Construction of Thoughts During Speech" or Heinrich von Kleist, "On the Gradual Production of Thoughts Whilst Speaking" and three BIG WORDS, numbered one, two, and three. Put your name at the top left of the document. Email all work to me at [email protected]

January 30 Thinking on Your Feet

Recommended Reading (read one or both of these two translations:

Heinrich von Kleist, "On the Gradual Construction of Thoughts During Speech"

Heinrich von Kleist, "On the Gradual Production of Thoughts Whilst Speaking"

In class, I will spontaneously cold call on you to talk extemporaneously about a passage I will spontaneously chose.

Kleist: Selected Writings (Hackett Classics) 2004

Recommended:

Stephen Greenblatt, "Introduction: Shakespeare's Montaigne," pp ix-xxxiii.

John Florio, Queen Anna's New World of Words

Thursday, January 31: No DQs due.

Friday, February 1

REQUIRED READING:

Arthur Schopenhauer, "Thinking for Oneself, " in PARERGA AND PARALIPOMENA, VOLUME 2 Chapter 22

Recommended Reading:

Stanley Cavell, "Introduction," in Cities of Words (2004).

At Berkeley (dir. Frederick Wiseman, 2013)

John Aubrey, Brief Lives

pp. vii; 1-9; 96-99; 102-05; 110-115; 173-77; 339-47; 382-88; 399-432.

It Happened One Night (dir. Frank Capra, )

Stanley Cavell, Knowledge as Transgression: Mostly a Reading of "It Happened One Night" Daedalus Daedalus Vol. 109, No. 2, Intellect and Imagination: The Limits and Presuppositions of Intellectual Inquiry (Spring, 1980), pp. 147-175

"The 2008 crash finds its antecedents in the manipulation of the gold market by Fisk and Gould in 1869, the Credit Mobilier Scandal of 1872, the Panic of 1873, the Crash of 1907, and of course the Great Depression, starting on Black Thursday, October 24, 1929, when the stock market crashed."

The early crashes were actually depressions, like the Great Depression. They just aren't called that for obvious reasons.

From Big Bang to Big Crash: The Early Origins of the UK’s Finance-led Growth Model and the Persistence of Bad Policy Ideas Tami Oren O & Mark Blyth Published online: 21 May 2018

Tuckett, Elizabeth, Beaten tracks; or, Pen and pencil sketches in Italy.By the authoress of "A voyage en zigzag".

Immanuel Kant, Essay on the Maladies of the Head

Opinion, taste, and public opinion

BBC documentary Hypernormalization

Stoicism as one response to skepticism

For others, look to Cavell and Adorno on manfacturing Public Opionion

Literature / metaphor as the problem / solution to the impasses of public opinion

Aesthetic judgment before and after Kant

Two examples skepticism as misunderstood by the smug, vacuous, complacent, self-entitled, "we know better," pontificating, "serious," (new, neo-) liberal elites in academia:

Miller, J. Hillis. “Presidential Address 1986: The Triumph of Theory, the Resistance to Reading, and the Question of the Material Base.” PMLA.

fonds_ancien_bibliotheque

La médecine judiciaire dans les collections de la bibliothèque de la Cour de cassation

Montaigne_essais_traduction_livres1-23

Cultivating Humanity: A Classical Defense of Reform in Liberal Education

Nietzsche: The Gay Science: With a Prelude in German Rhymes and an Appendix of Songs

Nothing Below Is Required:

. Two discussion questions on, numbered one and two, and Three Shots. Put your name at the top of the document. Email all work to me at [email protected]

At this point in the semester, I am now going to introduce a new game we will play irregularly. This is the game: I show you two passages, each taken from two books I've been reading recently, and will have you read them. The passages are both good, so I expect not everyone in the class will agree. Then you have to write down your answer. Then I will twll you the correct answer. Don't worry if you lose. I'll explain very carefully concisely why the students who agree with me and me are correct. :)

§257

Just as the largest library when not properly arranged does not provide as much use as a very moderate but well arranged one, so the greatest amount of knowledge, if not worked through by one's own thinking, has much less value than a far lesser quantity that has been thought through in various ways. For only through the universal combination of what we know, and comparing every truth with every other, do we completely assimilate our own knowledge and take control of it. One can only think through what one knows, which is why we should learn something; but one also knows only what has been thought through.

Now we can always apply ourselves arbitrarily to reading and learning, whereas to thinking we really cannot. For thinking must be kindled and sustained like a fire by a draught of air; there must be some interest in its subject, which may be purely objective or merely subjective. The latter is only present in our personal affairs, but the former is only for those minds who think by nature, for whom thinking is as natural as breathing, but who are very rare. Therefore in most scholars there is so little of it.

§258

The difference between the effect that thinking for oneself has on the mind, versus that of reading is incredibly large, which is why it constantly magnifies the original difference between minds, by virtue of which we are driven to one or the other. Reading, that is, forces thoughts on the mind that are as foreign and heterogeneous to its momentary direction and mood as is the seal to the wax on which it presses its imprint. The mind here experiences a total external compulsion to think this or that at random, for which it simply has no inclination or mood. – On the other hand, with thinking for oneself it follows its own peculiar drive, as this for the moment was more specifically determined by either the external environment or some recollection. For the intuitive environment does not force one specific thought on the mind, like reading; instead, it provides the mind with material and occasion to think what is in accordance with its nature and present mood.

Kierkegaard on chatter

Heidegger on "idle speech" and "They."

No Explaining

Arthur Schopenhauer, "On Noise," in Studies in Pessimism

Walter Benjamin on Montaigne on Herodotus

Due Tuesday, January 29 by 5:00 p.m. You Know the Drill:Two discussion questions on Michel de Montaigne, "Apology for Raymond Sebond" as well as three BIG WORDS, numbered one, two, and three. Put your name at the top left of the document. Email all work to me at [email protected] I will no longer post due dates since you now know when they are due.

Kleist: Selected Writings (Hackett Classics) 2004

M Pierre Bayard "Chapter IV Books You Have Forgotten" in How to Talk About Books You Haven't Read 2007, 32-46

W Montaigne "Of Books"

F Open At UC Berkeley. Frederick Wiseman

--Michel de Montaigne, "Of Bookes"

"UMass Says You Can't Say 'Fuck Nazis' Because It's Not Inclusive"

Netflix's Patriot Act: Neoliberal Establishment Authoritarian "News Comedy" on Social Media and Free Speech

Netflix Pulls Episode of Hasan Minhaj’s Show for Criticizing Saudi Arabia over Khashoggi Killing